Faddy holds out?

sme · Joined: 17 Aug 2007 Posts: 202

McFadden left Birmingham without agreeing terms and is to meet a mystery
club who are in for him.

http://tinyurl.com/34jj5y

--
sme

Archived from group: uk>sport>football>clubs>celtic

liam · Joined: 17 Aug 2007 Posts: 229

"sme" wrote
>
> McFadden left Birmingham without agreeing terms and is to meet a mystery
> club who are in for him.
>
> http://tinyurl.com/34jj5y

If Everton are demanding around £6m for him...I hope it's no' us...

Will · Joined: 17 Aug 2007 Posts: 780

liam wrote:
> "sme" wrote
>> McFadden left Birmingham without agreeing terms and is to meet a mystery
>> club who are in for him.
>>
>> http://tinyurl.com/34jj5y
>
> If Everton are demanding around £6m for him...I hope it's no' us...
>
>

I totally agree, I'd take the lad for £2.5m but any more is crazy.

Shopping in the EPL is like going on a pub crawl in Reykjavik - lots of
fun but really f'ing stupid.

celticbhoy60 · Joined: 09 Jan 2008 Posts: 17

"Will" wrote in message $4t5$1@registered.motzarella.org...
> liam wrote:
>> "sme" wrote
>>> McFadden left Birmingham without agreeing terms and is to meet a mystery
>>> club who are in for him.
>>>
>>> http://tinyurl.com/34jj5y
>>
>> If Everton are demanding around £6m for him...I hope it's no' us...
>
>
> I totally agree, I'd take the lad for £2.5m but any more is crazy.
>
> Shopping in the EPL is like going on a pub crawl in Reykjavik - lots of
> fun but really f'ing stupid.

£2.5 is a bit much to I think. He's a £1m player and no more

liam · Joined: 17 Aug 2007 Posts: 229

"Will" wrote
> liam wrote:
>> "sme" wrote
>>> McFadden left Birmingham without agreeing terms and is to meet a mystery
>>> club who are in for him.
>>>
>>> http://tinyurl.com/34jj5y
>>
>> If Everton are demanding around £6m for him...I hope it's no' us...
>
> I totally agree, I'd take the lad for £2.5m but any more is crazy.
>
> Shopping in the EPL is like going on a pub crawl in Reykjavik - lots of
> fun but really f'ing stupid.

The BBC are suggesting that Birmingham and Everton split the difference
between their valuations...but it's still alot of cash for Faddy......I'd
rather we'd splashed the cash on Barry Robson...

Will · Joined: 17 Aug 2007 Posts: 780

liam wrote:
> "Will" wrote
>> liam wrote:
>>> "sme" wrote
>>>> McFadden left Birmingham without agreeing terms and is to meet a mystery
>>>> club who are in for him.
>>>>
>>>> http://tinyurl.com/34jj5y
>>> If Everton are demanding around £6m for him...I hope it's no' us...
>> I totally agree, I'd take the lad for £2.5m but any more is crazy.
>>
>> Shopping in the EPL is like going on a pub crawl in Reykjavik - lots of
>> fun but really f'ing stupid.
>
> The BBC are suggesting that Birmingham and Everton split the difference
> between their valuations...but it's still alot of cash for Faddy......I'd
> rather we'd splashed the cash on Barry Robson...
>
>

I'd take Robson but only as a replacement for Jarosik, and certainly for
no more than a million. I see them as being fairly similar, but Robson
is a few years younger and would be a lot cheaper to run.

I'd like to see players leave before we bring any more in.

Will · Joined: 17 Aug 2007 Posts: 780

liam wrote:
> "Will" wrote
>> liam wrote:
>>> "sme" wrote
>>>> McFadden left Birmingham without agreeing terms and is to meet a mystery
>>>> club who are in for him.
>>>>
>>>> http://tinyurl.com/34jj5y
>>> If Everton are demanding around £6m for him...I hope it's no' us...
>> I totally agree, I'd take the lad for £2.5m but any more is crazy.
>>
>> Shopping in the EPL is like going on a pub crawl in Reykjavik - lots of
>> fun but really f'ing stupid.
>
> The BBC are suggesting that Birmingham and Everton split the difference
> between their valuations...but it's still alot of cash for Faddy......I'd
> rather we'd splashed the cash on Barry Robson...
>
>

I'd take Robson but only as a replacement for Jarosik, and certainly for
no more than a million. I see them as being fairly similar, but Robson
is a few years younger and would be a lot cheaper to run.

celticbhoy60 · Joined: 09 Jan 2008 Posts: 17

"Will" wrote in message $g2m$1@registered.motzarella.org...
> liam wrote:
>> "Will" wrote
>>> liam wrote:
>>>> "sme" wrote
>>>>> McFadden left Birmingham without agreeing terms and is to meet a
>>>>> mystery
>>>>> club who are in for him.
>>>>>
>>>>> http://tinyurl.com/34jj5y
>>>> If Everton are demanding around £6m for him...I hope it's no' us...
>>> I totally agree, I'd take the lad for £2.5m but any more is crazy.
>>>
>>> Shopping in the EPL is like going on a pub crawl in Reykjavik - lots of
>>> fun but really f'ing stupid.
>>
>> The BBC are suggesting that Birmingham and Everton split the difference
>> between their valuations...but it's still alot of cash for Faddy......I'd
>> rather we'd splashed the cash on Barry Robson...
>
>
> I'd take Robson but only as a replacement for Jarosik, and certainly for
> no more than a million. I see them as being fairly similar, but Robson is
> a few years younger and would be a lot cheaper to run.
>
> I'd like to see players leave before we bring any more in.

Like who?

Will · Joined: 17 Aug 2007 Posts: 780

celticbhoy60 wrote:
> "Will" wrote in message
> $g2m$1@registered.motzarella.org...
>> liam wrote:
>>> "Will" wrote
>>>> liam wrote:
>>>>> "sme" wrote
>>>>>> McFadden left Birmingham without agreeing terms and is to meet a
>>>>>> mystery
>>>>>> club who are in for him.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> http://tinyurl.com/34jj5y
>>>>> If Everton are demanding around £6m for him...I hope it's no' us...
>>>> I totally agree, I'd take the lad for £2.5m but any more is crazy.
>>>>
>>>> Shopping in the EPL is like going on a pub crawl in Reykjavik - lots of
>>>> fun but really f'ing stupid.
>>> The BBC are suggesting that Birmingham and Everton split the difference
>>> between their valuations...but it's still alot of cash for Faddy......I'd
>>> rather we'd splashed the cash on Barry Robson...
>>
>> I'd take Robson but only as a replacement for Jarosik, and certainly for
>> no more than a million. I see them as being fairly similar, but Robson is
>> a few years younger and would be a lot cheaper to run.
>>
>> I'd like to see players leave before we bring any more in.
>
> Like who?
>
>

Jarosik, Riordan, Maciej, Pressly, Gravesen.

liam* · Joined: 16 Nov 2007 Posts: 50

Will wrote:
> celticbhoy60 wrote:
> > "Will" wrote in message
> >$g2m$1@registered.motzarella.org...
> >> liam wrote:
> >>> "Will" wrote
> >>>> liam wrote:
> >>>>> "sme" wrote
> >>>>>> McFadden left Birmingham without agreeing terms and is to meet a
> >>>>>> mystery
> >>>>>> club who are in for him.
>
> >>>>>>http://tinyurl.com/34jj5y
> >>>>> If Everton are demanding around £6m for him...I hope it's no' us....
> >>>> I totally agree, I'd take the lad for £2.5m but any more is crazy.
>
> >>>> Shopping in the EPL is like going on a pub crawl in Reykjavik - lots of
> >>>> fun but really f'ing stupid.
> >>> The BBC are suggesting that Birmingham and Everton split the difference
> >>> between their valuations...but it's still alot of cash for Faddy......I'd
> >>> rather we'd splashed the cash on Barry Robson...
>
> >> I'd take Robson but only as a replacement for Jarosik, and certainly for
> >> no more than a million. I see them as being fairly similar, but Robson is
> >> a few years younger and would be a lot cheaper to run.
>
> >> I'd like to see players leave before we bring any more in.
>
> > Like who?
>
> Jarosik, Riordan, Maciej, Pressly, Gravesen.

You want the club to shift players, have a more sustainable wage
structure and additionally generate some transfer income before we
launch back into the transfer windows?!?....Celtic fans nowadays are
not what they used to be... Wink

thomas kaney · Joined: 17 Aug 2007 Posts: 4

caldwell, venegoor, donati
"Will" wrote in message $p2$1@registered.motzarella.org...
> celticbhoy60 wrote:
>> "Will" wrote in message
>> $g2m$1@registered.motzarella.org...
>>> liam wrote:
>>>> "Will" wrote
>>>>> liam wrote:
>>>>>> "sme" wrote
>>>>>>> McFadden left Birmingham without agreeing terms and is to meet a
>>>>>>> mystery
>>>>>>> club who are in for him.
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> http://tinyurl.com/34jj5y
>>>>>> If Everton are demanding around £6m for him...I hope it's no' us...
>>>>> I totally agree, I'd take the lad for £2.5m but any more is crazy.
>>>>>
>>>>> Shopping in the EPL is like going on a pub crawl in Reykjavik - lots
>>>>> of fun but really f'ing stupid.
>>>> The BBC are suggesting that Birmingham and Everton split the difference
>>>> between their valuations...but it's still alot of cash for
>>>> Faddy......I'd rather we'd splashed the cash on Barry Robson...
>>>
>>> I'd take Robson but only as a replacement for Jarosik, and certainly for
>>> no more than a million. I see them as being fairly similar, but Robson
>>> is a few years younger and would be a lot cheaper to run.
>>>
>>> I'd like to see players leave before we bring any more in.
>>
>> Like who?
>
> Jarosik, Riordan, Maciej, Pressly, Gravesen.

Will · Joined: 17 Aug 2007 Posts: 780

thomas kaney wrote:
> caldwell, venegoor, donati

Venegoor has been beyond fantastic for us since he joined. A scoring
rate of well over one in two and adds a lot more than goals to the side.

Nominating caldwell is the ignorant 'follow the pack' trendy card, but
doesn't stand up when examined closely. He's a very able centre back.

thomas kaney · Joined: 17 Aug 2007 Posts: 4

trust me celtic wont win a trophy for aslong as caldwell is at the heart of
that defence, as for jan voh,, we let a better player in hartson go for
peanuts
"Will" wrote in message $bg0$2@registered.motzarella.org...
> thomas kaney wrote:
>> caldwell, venegoor, donati
>
>
>
>
> Venegoor has been beyond fantastic for us since he joined. A scoring rate
> of well over one in two and adds a lot more than goals to the side.
>
>
> Nominating caldwell is the ignorant 'follow the pack' trendy card, but
> doesn't stand up when examined closely. He's a very able centre back.

Will · Joined: 17 Aug 2007 Posts: 780

thomas kaney wrote:
> trust me celtic wont win a trophy for aslong as caldwell is at the heart of
> that defence, as for jan voh,, we let a better player in hartson go for
> peanuts

The same JvOH that has a scoring record well over 1 in 2?
And the same Hartson that spent the last 4 months as Dion Dublins
understudy at Norwich, who are 18th in the Championship.

Interesting opinion.

liam* · Joined: 16 Nov 2007 Posts: 50

Will wrote:
> thomas kaney wrote:
> > trust me celtic wont win a trophy for aslong as caldwell is at the heart of
> > that defence, as for jan voh,, we let a better player in hartson go for
> > peanuts
>
> The same JvOH that has a scoring record well over 1 in 2?
> And the same Hartson that spent the last 4 months as Dion Dublins
> understudy at Norwich, who are 18th in the Championship.
>
> Interesting opinion.

Hartson did have a tendency to score against Them, and was a good
player for us in his prime....but I think Davie Weir might even give
Hartson a showing up for pace nowadays... Wink

Faddy fro's doon a marker... Man, what a slap in the face to big Eck, saying he wanted to sign for Celtic. Or maybe he's letting it be know that he wouldn't be averse to a move in the summer. But the question is, if Celtic keep playing they wonderful way they are playing at the momen

Faddy!! He can do no wrong at the moment! -- Blue Dave "Victory is mine!"

Faddy Everton will not allow Scotland international striker James McFadden to join Celtic. (Telegraph)

Faddy to Brum Can't get my head around this one. Mr. SUPER - Versatile going to a team that's going nowhere. & for peanuts. Fadds. is too good to even bother with a shite set-up like Birm. City. 3£M ...... We've been robbed. well & truly.

Ferguson at it again Not content with his team beating Arsenal 4-0, Ferguson is accusing the ref of favouritism and attacking the Arsenal players for dirty play. He obviously thinks this is the time for the mind games as we are in the last third of the season and his team nee